[2019] NZIACDT 23 — INZ (Calder) v Horan (John Wiremu Horan)

Immigration Advisers Complaints and Disciplinary Tribunal · decided 23 April 2019 · adviser: John Wiremu Horan

The tribunal's published summary

Sanctions decision / unprofessional & disrespectful communications with INZ / adviser made personal attacks against individual officers / adviser withheld information from client / adviser copied unconnected people in confidential client correspondence / Immigration Advisers Licensing Act 2007, s50, s51 / government agencies should not be unduly sensitive to criticism / communications crossed disciplinary threshold but not at upper end of unprofessional communications or malicious / withholding information isolated incident & did not cause decline of application / adviser refused to get clients’ consent to copy other people in correspondence / potential violations aggravated by contempt of code & disciplinary regime / adviser censured & ordered to pay $2,500 penalty.

Read the full decision (PDF, Ministry of Justice)

This page reproduces the tribunal's own published summary as a fair report of public tribunal proceedings; the linked decision is the authoritative record. A decision is not itself a finding of wrongdoing — some complaints are dismissed. Complainants are anonymised by the tribunal. Complaints about advisers go to the Immigration Advisers Authority.